Myceliary

A research project exploring anti-capitalist frameworks and patterns in AI/ML

Cannae Opportunities: AI That Exploits Capitalist Vulnerabilities

Technologies that turn capitalism’s greatest strengths into its greatest weaknesses


What Are Cannae Opportunities?

Drawing from Joan Westenberg’s analysis of the Cannae Problem - where success creates the very blind spots that lead to failure - we’ve identified 8 specific vulnerabilities in how capitalism approaches technology. Each vulnerability represents an opportunity to build community-controlled alternatives that capitalism literally cannot comprehend or compete with.

“Success creates its own failure mechanisms. The very things that make you successful produce the blind spots that make you vulnerable.” - Joan Westenberg

The 8 Opportunities

🌐 Ready Now (Start Today)

1. Augmentation Not Automation

Exploits: Automation Absolutism
Their Blind Spot: “Automate everything possible”
Our Opportunity: AI that enhances human craft and judgment rather than replacing it
Example: Craft augmentation tools that preserve artisan skills while improving sustainability

2. Hyperlocal AI Federations

Exploits: Scale-or-Die Mentality
Their Blind Spot: “If it doesn’t scale globally, it’s worthless”
Our Opportunity: Intentionally unscalable AI for specific neighborhoods
Example: Community garden AI that knows your exact soil and microclimate

3. Liberation Software

Exploits: Engagement Maximization Trap
Their Blind Spot: “Success = maximum user engagement”
Our Opportunity: Tools designed to make themselves unnecessary
Example: Language learning AI that celebrates when you no longer need it

🤝 Ready with Partners

4. Federated Community AI Networks

Exploits: AI Centralization Orthodoxy
Their Blind Spot: “AI requires massive centralized compute”
Our Opportunity: Small, distributed AI serving specific communities
Example: Indigenous language preservation networks

5. Collective Intelligence Amplifiers

Exploits: Individual Productivity Obsession
Their Blind Spot: “AI should make individuals more productive”
Our Opportunity: AI that amplifies group wisdom and consensus
Example: Participatory budgeting with emergence detection

6. Careful AI Development

Exploits: Innovation Speed Cult
Their Blind Spot: “Move fast and break things”
Our Opportunity: Slow, community-governed AI deployment
Example: Elder care AI developed with mandatory community review periods

🏗️ Foundation Building

7. Data Dignity Cooperatives

Exploits: Data Monetization Imperative
Their Blind Spot: “Data is the new oil - extract and refine”
Our Opportunity: Communities own their collective intelligence
Example: Medical AI cooperatives where patients control insights

8. Portable Identity Commons

Exploits: Platform Lock-in Strategy
Their Blind Spot: “Control the platform, control the value”
Our Opportunity: User-owned identity and reputation
Example: Gig worker reputation that travels between platforms

Why These Work

graph TD
    A[Capitalist Mental Model] --> B[Creates Blind Spot]
    B --> C[Community Alternative]
    C --> D[Exploits Vulnerability]
    D --> E[Capitalism Can't Compete]
    
    style A fill:#f9f,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style C fill:#9f9,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px
    style E fill:#ff9,stroke:#333,stroke-width:2px

Each opportunity works because it violates fundamental assumptions that capitalism cannot question without undermining its own logic:

  1. They optimize for extraction → We optimize for liberation
  2. They centralize control → We distribute sovereignty
  3. They maximize engagement → We celebrate graduation
  4. They scale infinitely → We serve specifically
  5. They automate humans out → We augment humans in

Getting Started

For Communities

  1. Assess Your Needs: Which capitalist blindspot affects your community most?
  2. Start Small: Begin with “Ready Now” opportunities that require minimal resources
  3. Find Partners: Connect with other communities facing similar challenges
  4. Access Resources: Download implementation guides and technical specifications

For Developers

  1. Choose Your Battle: Pick an opportunity that matches your skills and values
  2. Join the Movement: Connect with communities ready to implement
  3. Contribute Code: All specifications are open source and need builders
  4. Share Knowledge: Document your implementation for others

For Organizers

  1. Map Vulnerabilities: Identify which mental models dominate your sector
  2. Build Coalitions: Unite communities around specific opportunities
  3. Resource Mobilization: Access non-extractive funding sources
  4. Movement Building: Use implementations to demonstrate alternatives

Implementation Support

Each opportunity includes:

Success Stories

As communities implement these opportunities, we’ll share their stories here

Join the Revolution

These aren’t just technical projects - they’re acts of resistance. Each implementation demonstrates that another technological world is possible, one that serves human needs rather than capital accumulation.

Ready to exploit capitalism’s blind spots? Choose an opportunity above and start building the future.


Resources


“What worked before won’t work forever, and success today creates the conditions for failure tomorrow.” - Let’s position ourselves to be capitalism’s Hannibal.